Good Saddle, no issues

Saddle is comfortable and is light, but the outer of the carbon rails cracked to reveal a white underneath after a few weeks without crashing or drops.

Have this saddle on all my bikes, MTB, road, gravel, cyclocross. Not all have carbon rails but all are phenom.

I still like the phenom and at one time it was the best saddle for me and I still recommend it and it is a good price, but the S-Works Power with Mirror has taken over that spot and I recommend it to old faithful phenom fans as myself.

The rails are pushed very far forward by design compared to all other saddles and I've owned a lot (where you sit gets pushed backwards) so for fit my bike needed to change from a 25mm offset seat post to 0 offset. Both my bikes have this saddle and both needed new seat posts, ouch extra cost. Additionally, the S-Works version is a very different shape and padding profile from the Phenom Expert and Comp. I own both. So if you've tried one don't assume the other will work for you. Which is a bummer because they're named the same but one causes me chaffing and the S-Works doesn't (your mileage may very). That said, this is the most comfortable saddle I've ever ridden (mileage varying) which is why I bought 2. So the extra seat post cost is worth it for me.

I ride phenoms on all my bikes. great fit

I find this saddle to be ergonomically designed and a pleasure to use.

initial impression is it's good quality saddle, as expected for an sworks. . need more time to evaluate

Tried the Romin Evo mirror to take the place of my now retired Toupe. Didnt work right off the bat. Went to this Phenom based on other reviews of previous Toupe riders saying the Phenom was just as good as the Touple, if not better. I agree, love this Phenom. Use it on my Roubaix. This is not just an MTB saddle.

At the second ride, both rails broke like nothing. Bought a carbon fiber repair kit and had them glued back on. First ride after reparation, rails snapped again, different places this time. Definitely, they are weak. Hopefully, Specialized team will get it fixed.